TGA Digital Scribe Review: Is Your AI Tool a Medical Device?
Published: 23/10/2026 | Reading time: 6 minutes
In short: The TGA reviewed 12 digital scribes. None of the suppliers said their product was a medical device, and eight had functions likely to be. The TGA judges a product by what it is intended to do and how it is marketed, not by a disclaimer. Last reviewed 26 October 2026.
On 16 October 2026, the Therapeutic Goods Administration published the outcomes of its review of digital scribes supplied in Australia. It identified around 100 suppliers, received survey responses from 40, and looked closely at 12 products, including some of the most widely used in the country.
None of the 12 suppliers identified their product as a medical device. The TGA found that eight included functions likely to meet the definition of one.
The TGA hasn’t said which eight. If your practice uses one of the 12 products reviewed, you have no way of knowing from the report whether yours is on the list.
The review didn’t test products, check safety and performance, or assess compliance with detailed device requirements. The TGA says it will use the findings to guide targeted compliance activities where a digital scribe’s functionality meets the definition of a medical device, using a proportionate, risk-based approach. In August, TGA product quality division head Tracey Duffy told the HIC2026 conference: “When it comes to digital scribes, this review has moved into compliance action.” (The Medical Republic)
When a scribe stops being a scribe
Most digital scribes started as transcription and documentation tools. Many have added features since. The TGA put it plainly:
“Many digital scribes now include advanced generative AI-enabled functions that go beyond transcription and summarisation. These features analyse information, determine what is clinically relevant, or generate clinical conclusions, recommendations or other outputs that may influence diagnosis, monitoring, prognosis or treatment of a disease, injury, disability or condition. Products that perform these types of functions are likely to meet the definition of a medical device.”
In its digital scribes guidance, the TGA says a scribe is likely to be a medical device if it suggests diagnoses, recommends treatments or investigations, triages or prioritises patients, or generates clinical conclusions. Medical devices must be included in the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods (ARTG) unless they’re exempt, and even exempt devices, such as some clinical decision support software, are still regulated.
“Not a medical device” isn’t a defence
The review found a gap between what suppliers said and what their products did:
“While none of the suppliers identified their product as a medical device our review found that many included functions likely to meet the definition of a medical device.”
Many relied on disclaimers. The TGA was clear that this doesn’t work:
“Some products included statements that they were not a medical device, or they were not intended for diagnosis, treatment or other medical purposes. Statements or disclaimers are not sufficient in determining if a product is, or is not, a medical device.”
What a product does, and how it’s marketed, decides its status. The label on the box doesn’t.
How the TGA decides
The TGA looks at a product’s intended purpose. It works that out from the product’s labelling, instructions for use, advertising, website and other marketing, and technical documentation, as well as what the software can do. A product can have both medical device and non-medical device functions.
Two of the TGA’s own examples show how this plays out:
- A scribe with only administrative functions is still a medical device if the maker claims it guides diagnosis and treatment planning or improves patient outcomes (the TGA’s Example 7).
- A scribe sold as a documentation tool, but with an “insights” feature that suggests diagnoses, follow-up or treatment options, is a medical device. A disclaimer in the product doesn’t change that (Example 6).
The TGA also describes a scribe that files transcripts to the patient record and places follow-up orders without any clinician review. That is a medical device too (Example 8).
Why this lands on your desk
The TGA’s guidance says health professionals should regularly assess whether the software they use remains appropriate and compliant. It lists things to consider:
- whether the product meets the definition of a medical device and, if so, whether it is on the ARTG or exempt
- whether software updates have introduced functions that change its intended purpose
- whether appropriate data protection and privacy safeguards are in place
- whether the product continues to perform as expected
- whether another way of recording is available for patients who ask for it
The updates point matters, because the TGA found existing products adding features throughout the review. If a vendor says its product is a medical device, you can check the ARTG using the manufacturer’s name.
The guidance also says you are responsible for obtaining informed consent from patients and for verifying the accuracy of information entered into a patient’s health record.
For practice managers, this is now a procurement and governance question, not just an IT one.
Where the line sits
Not every digital scribe is a medical device. The TGA says whether one is regulated depends on its intended purpose and functionality, “including whether it is intended to support or influence diagnosis, monitoring, prognosis or treatment of a disease, injury, disability or condition.”
The TGA says digital scribes intended only to perform administrative tasks are not medical devices. The administrative functions it lists include recording and transcribing conversations, organising information, summarising conversations, drafting clinical documentation such as notes, referral letters and clinical correspondence, and formatting information into structured fields for the health professional to review and confirm. Functions that analyse information, decide what is clinically relevant or generate clinical conclusions or recommendations are where it says products are likely to meet the definition of a medical device.
Clinician review doesn’t take a product out of regulation on its own. The TGA says a digital scribe whose only purpose is to give a recommendation to a health professional may be exempt clinical decision support software, but exempt software is still a regulated medical device that must comply with regulatory requirements.
What practice managers should do now
- Ask each vendor the questions at the end of this article, and keep their answers in writing.
- If a vendor says its product is a medical device, ask to see its ARTG entry or exemption. An administrative scribe isn’t required to be on the register, so a missing entry doesn’t settle anything either way. What matters is what the product does and how it is marketed.
- Read the vendor’s website and marketing for claims about diagnosis, treatment or patient outcomes. The TGA treats these as evidence of intended purpose.
- Ask how the vendor tells you when features change, and look again after major updates.
- Make sure patients are told when a scribe is used, can ask for another way of recording, and that you have their informed consent.
What Dict8ion does, and doesn’t do
Dict8ion was not one of the 12 products the TGA reviewed closely. That doesn’t settle anything, because the TGA looks at what a product does and how it is marketed. Here is exactly what Dict8ion does and doesn’t do.
Dict8ion is a dictation tool for patient letters. The doctor dictates after the consultation, using a dictaphone, a voice app or the Dict8ion app. The AI transcribes the dictation and tidies grammar and formatting. The practice team or doctor then proofs the letter before it goes out.
Dict8ion doesn’t listen to consultations. It doesn’t summarise, analyse or interpret what the doctor says, and it doesn’t suggest diagnoses, treatments, investigations or follow-up. The clinical content of every letter is the doctor’s.
The workflow is designed for the doctor to approve each letter. The original audio recording sits alongside the transcript, so whoever reviews the letter can check it against what was said. Dict8ion doesn’t write into the clinical record. Your team copies the approved letter into your own software.
“We have always taken a workflow-and-workforce-first approach. Getting information in and out of a practice accurately, on time and with the least stress matters to admin staff, patients and clinicians alike,” says Yupin Robson, CEO of Dict8ion. “That is why we built an AI workflow system with a human in the loop. Every letter is designed to be checked by a person, with the original audio on hand, so accuracy, traceability and accountability are part of the process.”
For context, the TGA’s guidance names drafting referral letters and other clinical correspondence, and formatting information for the health professional to review and confirm, among administrative functions.
This describes how the product works. It isn’t a statement about its regulatory status, and it isn’t regulatory or legal advice. How the guidance applies to any product depends on its intended purpose and how it is marketed, so read it for yourself. Whatever tool you use, ask the vendor the same questions.
Eight questions to ask your scribe or dictation vendor
- Does the product ever add clinical content I didn’t say?
- Does it suggest diagnoses, treatments, investigations or follow-up?
- Do you say your product is a medical device? If so, can you show me its ARTG entry or exemption? If not, what are you basing that on?
- What features have you added in the last 12 months?
- Does your marketing claim it supports diagnosis or improves patient outcomes?
- Does it write into our clinical records automatically?
- How do you tell customers when features change, and how do you check whether a change affects the product’s purpose?
If the answers aren’t clear, that tells you something.
Read the TGA’s full digital scribe review outcomes and its digital scribes guidance. For clinicians, the ACSQHC publishes Pragmatic AI guidance. More on how Dict8ion works: our FAQ and Dict8ion vs AI scribes.
This article summarises published TGA material as at 26 October 2026. It is general information, not legal or regulatory advice. Check the TGA pages for the current position.
See how Dict8ion fits your role:
Doctors and specialists | Practice managers | Admin staff | Case studies